|Researchers found an error in, Ancient Ethiopian genome reveals extensive Eurasian admixture in Eastern Africa BY |
SCIENCE : 820-822. This was an important article because it maintained that there was extensive Eurasian admixture in Africa.
quote:If you read the paper above we learn two things that made it necessary to dispute this paper.
Firstly, this paper made it clear that Mota man's evidence of Eurasian genes was deliberately blocked. As a result, it indicated that Ethiopians were carry Eurasian genes long before their is evidence of of Eurasians migrating into Africa.
Any researcher worth his salt, could flip the script and show that the so-called Eurasian genes found in Mota man prove the African origin of many so-called Middle Eastern caucasian haplogroups.
Secondly, the researchers of MOta man reported that he carried Neanderthal DNA. This finding could not be allowed to stand. Because it confirmed the finding of Prufer 2013 of a relationship between Altaic Neanderthals and Africans. The idea that Mota man was related to the Neanderthals had to be reversed, because this finding disputed the myth that only Eurasians carried Neanderthal genes, and that Eurasians were a unique AMH because Africans did not carry Neanderthal genes.
An exception to this norm are the Khoisan who share a phylogenic relationship with Altai Neanderthals (Prufer, et al, 2013). Many researchers claim that Africans have no relationship to the Neanderthals.But Prufer et al (2013) share more alleles with Altaic Neanderthal than Denisova.
In the Supplemental section of Prufer et al (2013) there is considerable discussion of the relationship between Neanderthal and Khoisan. In relation to the Altaic Neanderthal the non-Africans have a lower divergence rate than Africans between 10-20%. Prufer et al (2013) note little statistical difference between non-African and African divergence.
Researchers have observered a relationship between the Neanderthals, the Khoisan and Yoruba. Prufer et al (2013) detected a relationship between the Neanderthal and Mandekan. It is interesting to note that Yoruba traditions place them in Mande-speaking areas (Prufer et al,2013).
There is interesting information in Figure S7.1. In Figure S7.1 the maximum likelihood tree of bonobo, Denisova and Neanderthal, the closest present-day hmans are Africans, not Europeans. Reading the Tree Chart Graph, the neighbor joining tree of archaic and present day human individuals has the Khoisan following the Denisova.These points were major reasons why the Mota paper had to be found in error. But the most important reason for the disavowal of the Mota article was the finding that as much as 6–7% of the ancestry of West and Central African groups came from the Eurasian migrants.
This finding had to be eliminated because there is no evidence that Eurasians made their way to West and Central Africa. Since Eurasians were not in West and Central Africa, the so-called Eurasian admixture among these groups reflected the fact that the Eurasian genome, is really West and Central African not Eurasian.
The discovery of Eurasian "admixture" among West Africans is not a recent discovery. Pickrell et al (2014) found that the Mande people carry 2% Eurasian admixture. This supports the claim of the authors of the Mota article.
If it has been known since 2014 that West Africans were carrying Eurasian admixture the findings of, the authors of the Mota article that as much as 6–7% of the ancestry of West and Central African groups was "Eurasian" was not an error.
But like R1-V88, the "Eurasian" admixture, found among the West Africans in East, Central, West and South Africa is in reality African genomes passed onto the Eurasians when the Kushites migrated into Eurasia after the Great Flood. Other "Eurasian" genomes of African origin were deposited in Eurasia first by the Khoisan and later the Anu (Pygmies) that ruled Eurasia up to the Great Flood.
As you can see from the case of Mota man, analysis of aDNA from Africans can upset the status quo. It destroys the protocols of Structure and Admixture programs that maintain Africans and Eurasians only came in contact after 1492 due to the Atlantic slave trade.
Joseph K. Pickrell, Nick Patterson, Po-Ru Loh, Mark Lipson, Bonnie Berger, Mark Stoneking, Brigitte Pakendorf, and David Reich.(2014). Ancient west Eurasian ancestry in southern and eastern Africa. PNAS 2014 111 (7) 2632-2637.
K. Prufer et al (2014).The complete genome sequence of a Neanderthal from the Altai Mountains. Nature. 2014 Jan 2;505(7481):43-9. doi: 10.1038/nature12886. Epub 2013 Dec 18.
Saturday, December 30, 2017
Why Researchers found an error in, Ancient Ethiopian genome reveals extensive Eurasian admixture in Eastern Africa , by M. GALLEGO LLORENTE
Posted by Dr. Clyde Winters at 6:56 AM
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Post a Comment